My Friend is a Palestinian Bedouin: V. Data Collection and Analysis

My Friend is a Palestinian Bedouin: V. Data Collection and Analysis

Although Bashar offered invaluable input as part of this study, the focus will be on my experience in the friendship and on the challenges and opportunities for me (and not on those for him). In most descriptions the emphasis will be on the contrast between Bedouin and Dutch cultures, since the cultural variations between these cultures are most distinct. Israeli culture, which provides another part of the context of the friendship and affects both of us, is hard to define because of its heterogeneity. For both reasons, the impact of Israeli culture on the friendship is much more subtle. In most topics its description will be limited, unless highly relevant for the specific topic. Note that the discussion of each topic is not intended to be exhaustive, but rather attempts to display the cultural differences that need to be dealt with within an intercultural friendship.

It needs to be clear that the cultural dimensions described in this study relate to the environments that affected us, and not necessarily to our own personal values. Hofstede’s four dimensions (Hofstede, 2001) are used here as a perspective. No attempt was made to measure our personal value systems. In any case, it was suggested that the “signs of cultural difference cannot then be unitary or individual forms of identity because their continual implication in other symbolic systems always leaves them ‘incomplete’ or open to cultural translation” (Bhabha, 1994, p. 313).

Notes of Caution

Three broad issues need to be emphasized while interpreting the findings in this study; these are cultural relativism, issues of reliability and validity, and selectivity of information.

Cultural relativism

This study required making certain cultural comparisons. Comparisons will be based on generalizations deriving from the dominant cultures in which we grew up. Throughout this study, I have drawn on the term “Western” cultures, but this is actually an over-simplification of the situation, because it does injustice to the large variety of cultures – both between and within nations – in Western Europe and the United States. Unless stated differently, I will use the term “Western” as referring to Caucasians with middle class status, Euro-American upbringing and Judeo-Christian roots.

As regarding cultural identity, it seems that in practice it is difficult to provide exact definitions of one’s identity even though instruments for measuring cultural identity exist. This is because people may attribute to themselves characteristics of several cultural groups (Benish-Weisman & Horenczyk, 2010). It is impossible to point at the precise differences between Bedouin, Palestinian and Muslim – and Israeli – cultures that are part of Bashar’s identity. Likewise, it is difficult to make a clear separation between Israeli and Jewish cultures, which are both part of my cultural identity.

Attachments

Share this:

About the Author

Daniel Weishut

Daniel WeishutDaniel J.N. Weishut, born in the Netherlands but living in Jerusalem, is a professional with a diverse background. He holds an MA in Clinical Psychology and an MBA in Integrative Business Administration, both from the Hebrew University in Jerusalem, and a PsyD in Clinical and Organizational Psychology from the Professional School of Psychology (Sacramento). He has about thirty years of experience in consultation and therapy with a wide variety of clients and issues, more than twenty years of practice in group facilitation, and over fifteen years of know-how in governance and management in various organizations. Daniel Weishut offers his services as a "Partner on the Way", while taking a world-view that people are diverse but equal. He works with a variety of clients, but his special interest is in work with those who have found themselves persecuted or otherwise in conflict with their social environment, because of their culture, identity or belief system. For example: migrants, expats, refugees, Holocaust survivors, soldiers, pacifists, and individuals from religious, cultural or sexual minorities. Daniel Weishut is a social activist and in this capacity he volunteers as Chairperson of the Israeli Association of Group Psychotherapy, as Member of the Membership Appeals Committee of Amnesty International and as forensic expert for the Public Committee Against Torture in Israel. He also is involved in raising awareness about the situation of Bedouins around Jerusalem; awareness which led among others to the writing of his dissertation "My friend is a Palestinian Bedouin: Challenges and opportunities in intercultural friendship".

View all posts by Daniel Weishut

Leave a Reply